Zillow vs. MLS: Unmasking the Real Estate Search Beasts in NYC!

Cracking the code of New York City’s real estate market can feel like solving a Rubik’s Cube blindfolded.
Yes, searching for home for sale in the different online Real Estate platforms is your first step,
but, at the same time, it can easily get you confused. so which platform works better?!
Let’s compare between the two titans which are dominating the online real estate search for a landscape:
Zillow and the Multiple Listing Service (MLS).
Let’s dissect their strengths and weaknesses to empower your NYC property hunt.

Pros and Cons of Zillow and MLS:



  • Vast Listings:
    Zillow boasts an extensive database of real estate listings,
    making it a one-stop-shop for property searches.
  • User-Friendly Interface:
    Zillow’s intuitive interface and interactive tools simplify the search process for buyers.
  • Market Insights:
    Zillow’s Zestimate tool provides estimated property values and market trends,
    which are offering valuable insights to buyers and sellers alike.


  • Accuracy Concerns:
    Zillow’s Zestimate feature may not always reflect accurate property values,
    leading to potential discrepancies.
  • Third-Party Listings:
    Zillow includes listings from various sources, including third-party syndicated listings,
    which may result in potentially outdated or duplicate listings.



  • Accuracy and Reliability:
    MLS offers comprehensive and accurate data sourced directly from real estate professionals,
    ensuring reliable listings and market information.
  • Exclusive Listings:
    MLS includes exclusive listings not available on public platforms,
    giving buyers access to unique opportunities.
  • Customized Searches:
    MLS allows users to tailor their searches based on their specific criteria,
    buyers are able to define their property type, price range, as well as many different types of amenities.


  • Restricted Access:
    MLS is primarily accessible to licensed real estate agents and brokers,
    limiting direct access for individual buyers and sellers.
  • Regional Variations:
    MLS data may vary by region or market,
    with some areas having more comprehensive listings than others.

Reliability and User-Friendliness:

In terms of reliability and user-friendliness,
MLS stands out for its accuracy and trustworthiness in providing up-to-date and verified listings.
While Zillow offers a user-friendly interface and market insights,
its accuracy can sometimes potentially be a point of contention.
Therefore, for buyers seeking reliable and accurate information, MLS is often considered the preferred choice.

Best Platform for Each Borough and Property Type:

  • Manhattan:
    Both Zillow and MLS offer comprehensive listings for single-family and multi-family homes in Manhattan.
    However, MLS may provide more exclusive opportunities and accurate data
    for buyers seeking premium properties in this borough.
  • Brooklyn:
    MLS is well-suited for buyers in Brooklyn, offering a wide range of listings,
    including single-family and multi-family homes, condos, and townhouses in Brooklyn.
    Zillow can also be useful for exploring neighborhoods and market trends.
  • Queens:
    MLS is highly recommended for houses for sale in Queens,
    known for its accuracy and comprehensive listings across property types.
    Zillow can complement MLS by providing additional market insights.
  • The Bronx:
    MLS is a reliable choice for buyers looking for houses in The Bronx,
    offering accurate data and exclusive listings.
    Zillow can be used for supplemental information and neighborhood exploration.
  • Staten Island:
    MLS is beneficial for buyers in Staten Island, providing detailed listings and customized search options.
    Zillow’s market trends and Zestimate tool can offer additional perspectives.

Importance of Working with an Experienced Agent:

To summerize the above comparison, Zillow and MLS are both valuable resources,
However, the key for a successful real estate transaction is working with an experienced and reliable agent.
An agent can provide personalized guidance, negotiate on your behalf, and navigate complex processes,
ensuring a seamless and satisfying experience.
Home Mega offers a game-changing advantage: direct access to all the MLS listings in New York,
including the most coveted single-family homes and multi-family properties.
Partner with a dedicated, MLS-certified Home Mega agent and unlock the secrets of the NYC real estate market.
Don’t navigate this jungle alone!
Contact us at Home Mega today and let our experienced, client-adored agents guide you towards your dream NYC home,
be it a single-family haven or a multi-family goldmine.

Call us today to work with us as your trusted broker and experience the difference with Home Mega!

(718) 808-2030